Sugino's Good Design Award for the Barriquan tool

Manual vs. Automated Deburring

Barriquan Deburring Tool Holder in Use
CATEGORIES: ,

During machining of metal parts, unwanted protrusions known as burrs often form. The essential process of removing them is called deburring.  This process is often done manually, presenting challenges including human error, risk of injury, and stringent quality requirements. Deburring requires repeatability and consistency.

Futhermore, as manufacturing faces labor shortages the demand for automated deburring solutions increases.

However, automating manual deburring with a machining center or robot may not always deliver the desired results. Several factors, such as cutting tool wear, variations in workpiece dimensions, and mounting errors, can lead to inconsistent burr sizes and shapes, complicating the automation process.

That’s where Float Deburring comes in – Barriquan provides a machining method with a floating mechanism that aligns the tool perfectly with the workpiece’s shape, preventing over-shaving and ensuring that no burrs are left behind. The tool maintains a consistent pressure along the workpiece, and self-compensates. It is an effective deburring option that delivers precise and reliable results every time.

Before and after burr removal with Sugino Barriquan deburring tool
Before and after with Barriquan’s self-compensating deburring solution.

About the float mechanism and attachments

Barriquan excels at deburring thanks to a floating mechanism that uses springs and compressed air to push the tool against and along the workpiece at a consistent pressure.  The mechanism is available in different configurations for flexibility – it may be built into a tool holder or spindle motor, or as an independent unit.

Sugino Barriquan BRQ-TX01 float deburring tool holder

Different Methods of Float Deburring 

AXIALLY FLOATING TYPE

The axially floating type utilizes a mechanism that extends and retracts in the Z direction. It is ideal for deburring the edges of workpieces and is often used to deburr the contours of castings, and burrs that remain after machining.

Sugino Barriquan deburring tool holder with float mechanism to maintain consistent pressure

TILTING FLOATING TYPE

With this type, the tool is tilted to the workpiece. Suitable for protrusions and burrs that occur on the “surface” rather than the edge of a workpiece. It is often used for parting line removal of aluminum die castings, etc., and is mainly suitable for deburring using robots.

Sugino Barriquan deburring tool features tilt mechanism so tool is tilted to the workpiece

Manual vs. Automated Deburring: Human Judgement vs. Robotic Precision

One of the biggest challenges in automating deburring is replicating the human ability to perceive, judge, and apply a “knack” for the task. While vision cameras, sensors, and software can mimic human senses and decision-making to some extent, they struggle with processing ambiguous information as effectively as a human can.

Automated systems must go through multiple steps—inputting information, calculating, and then executing actions. This process can slow down deburring, especially when high-speed processing is required.

This is where the floating mechanism comes into play. It acts almost like an autonomic nervous system, responding to subtle, ambiguous variations without the need for conscious input. By directly reacting to these variations, the floating mechanism enables faster and more efficient deburring than what can be achieved with sensors and software alone.

Human judgement versus automated software decision making
A small articulated robot becomes a processing machine.

Articulated robots are widely used to automate transport and non-contact tasks, but are not suitable for tasks that require rigidity, such as metalworking.

As mentioned above, a floating mechanism can soften the load and impact on the robot, enabling automation of deburring even with a small multi-joint robot with low rigidity.

The floating mechanism also reduces teaching work and compensates for inaccurate trajectories, making it an excellent match for robot deburring.

The load on the robot with Sugino's float deburring tool Barriquan

See it in action: watch how the different Barriquan mechanisms work

AXIAL FLOAT MECHANISM

The axially floating mechanism floats vertically and follows along both the workpiece’s height (Z) and horizontal directions (XY).

Height direction (Z direction)

Even if the distance between the workpiece and the tool and the tool’s height changes, the tool stays with the workpiece due to the axially floating mechanism.

Horizontal direction (XY direction)

Even if the lateral distance between the workpiece and the tool changes, the tool follows the workpiece due to the expansion and contraction of the floating mechanism.

However, since the contact position between the tool and the workpiece changes, the distance that can be followed depends on the size of the tool.

Tilting Float Mechanism

The tilting mechanism tilts 360° and acts as a cushion where the tool meets the workpiece when approaching from any direction, as in robot teaching.

Sugino's Barriquan deburring tool holder and spindle is attached to a light payload robot to automate the deburring process

To learn more about the different types of tools / attachments that are appropriate for these methods, or specific models, please visit:


Key Takeaways

  • Burrs often form during machining, and deburring is crucial to remove them, but manual methods come with risks and inconsistencies.
  • Deburring challenges include tool wear and dimension variations, impacting outcome quality.
  • Barriquan’s Float Deburring tool uses a floating mechanism ensuring consistent pressure and better alignment with workpieces.
  • Different types of Float Deburring methods exist, such as axially floating and tilting types, suitable for various deburring tasks.
  • Automated systems can struggle with tasks requiring precision, but floating mechanisms help small robots perform deburring more effectively.